Chemical engineer Dr. Micah Green takes on one of the biggest questions scientists ask about faith, in a talk at Embry-Riddle.
Can you believe in miracles and still keep your science degree? Dr. Micah Green, Associate Department Head of Chemical Engineering at Texas A&M University, takes on three common myths about science and faith in this talk at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University.
He starts with scientism, the idea that you should only believe what science can prove, and shows why that claim undercuts itself. Using a billiards table illustration from C.S. Lewis, he explains why a miracle does not break the laws of physics, and why miracles in Scripture always carry a purpose. He then looks at what science can and cannot say about God, including the beginning of the universe and the fine-tuning of physical constants.
Micah closes with his own season of doubt as an MIT grad student, and with the evidence he found in the human mind itself: our rationality, consciousness, and sense of right and wrong. He ends by showing how Christian faith gave the first scientists their reason to study the natural world.
The talk was hosted by the Center for Faith and Spirituality at Embry-Riddle in Daytona Beach, with Grad Resources bringing Micah to campus.
At Texas A&M, we always start every class period by saying howdy, just to be extra Texas. So we're going to try that tonight. I say howdy, and you say howdy back. Howdy!
Audience: Howdy!
Okay, good. Sadly, at Texas A&M, howdy now basically means class is starting, so that's what we're doing today. Students, thank you for being here. I know some of you are thinking, "What I need at the end of a long day is a professor with PowerPoint slides." So we're going to try to go fast, and I'm going to leave a lot of time at the end for discussion.
Speaking of discussion, I want you to talk with the people around you. You get one minute. What are some ways you have been told that science and faith are in conflict? Go.
Okay, your minute is up. Let me hear from a couple of groups. What did you talk about?
Audience: Evolution.
Evolution. Okay. How about this group?
Audience: The creation of the earth.
Good, that's related. Anything else?
Audience: When life begins.
Oh, that's an interesting place where ethics and science come together. Yes, ma'am?
Audience: The physiological background behind miracles.
Yes, we're going to talk about miracles. Can I actually believe that's true and still keep my science degree? These are good.
Today I may not be able to go deep on specific questions about creation, the history of life, or the origin of life. But I want to speak big picture. When it comes to conflict between science and faith, you can have specific disagreements, like whether a particular event in the Bible actually happened. Or you can have big picture disagreements, like people who say science tells us miracles don't happen. I want to hit some of those big picture points by addressing a few myths.
Anybody heard this before? You'll hear it in various versions. You may hear it called scientism: science is the road to truth, and other roads to truth are not really trustworthy.
This has a long history. The philosopher William Kingdon Clifford was famous for saying, "It is wrong always, everywhere, and for anyone to believe anything upon insufficient evidence." In other words, if you believe something and can't back it up with evidence, you're doing something wrong. He's saying you actually have a duty not to believe something unless you have evidence.
So scientism, rephrased, says science is the only trustworthy means to objective truth. People rarely say that out loud, but you'll hear people draw a distinction between facts and opinions, and even then they're buying into this idea. If science is the only way to know what's true, and science only studies the natural world, then the natural world is all you can know anything about.
I want you to see how this is different from atheism. Atheism says there is no supernatural world. Scientism says you can't know anything beyond the natural world. This is associated with the philosopher David Hume, but you'll hear it on modern programs too. Carl Sagan had a program called Cosmos, which Neil deGrasse Tyson brought back not long ago. The message is: you can be religious and have that experience, but it isn't knowledge.
Some of you may already see a problem. Imagine a text message thread with David Hume. He says, "Only beliefs that can be proven through scientific experiments are trustworthy." The obvious question back is, "Can you prove that statement through scientific experiments?" And he has to say, "I don't know." Hume himself noticed this was a problem. If you set the bar that high, the rule fails its own test. It's like saying, "All sentences in English are a lie." That sentence would be a lie too, which doesn't make sense. So if you hear someone say it's wrong to believe anything on insufficient evidence, the obvious answer is: give me some evidence that's true.
Even so, scientism is everywhere. When I was an undergrad at my alma mater, Texas Tech, a classmate told me, "Micah, science has proven that our minds are purely physical and there's no such thing as a soul." When I asked what he meant, it turned out he meant we used our material microscopes to look for an immaterial soul, and we didn't find it. He assumed that if his microscope couldn't find it, it didn't exist. That's where scientism leads. A microscope is really good at what microscopes are good at. But as soon as you assume that if you can't see it with a microscope it doesn't exist, you limit what you are able to know.
There's an old illustration of a drunk man looking for his lost wallet under a streetlight. The police officer asks, "Is this where you lost it?" He says, "No, I lost it in the park, but this is where the light is." If you say you can only know things through science, you stay under that one light and assume everything outside it is unknowable.
So let me ask you: what is something science cannot investigate?
Audience: Love. The afterlife. How you should act.
Good, morality. We use science to describe what does happen. But we can't use science to tell us what should happen. C.S. Lewis made this point in his book Miracles. A scientist can tell Wile E. Coyote that he shouldn't stand under that big rock, but what we mean is that it would be imprudent. Science can't tell us that something is morally wrong or that you ought not do it.
When someone tells you that you can only believe what you can scientifically prove, the truth is you believe all kinds of things you can't prove by science. Science is wonderful for studying the natural world. That's what microscopes and telescopes are for. But it can't say anything about ethics, meaning, beauty, or purpose.
The Oxford mathematician John Lennox, whom I got to interview at A&M, gives a great illustration. If I ask why the water is boiling, the mechanical engineers in the room can give a long explanation about thermal energy, phase transitions, and thermodynamics. But Lennox says the reason the water is boiling is because he would like some tea. We can describe the water boiling scientifically, but "because John would like some tea" requires agency and purpose. Science is good at what it's good at, but it can't get everything.
You may have heard people say this, usually with a snooty tone about ancient people: "Ancient people thought miracles like a virgin birth were possible, but now, thanks to science, we know it can't happen." That attitude is chronological snobbery, the idea that we know a lot and ancient people didn't know very much.
Imagine going back and telling Joseph, "Joseph, you know virgin births are impossible, right?" He'd say, "I know. I've got it." So why the disconnect with Joseph?
It has to do with the history of science during the Enlightenment. Isaac Newton wrote the Principia Mathematica, combining calculus and Latin, maybe your two least favorite subjects. It hugely influenced the scientists of his time, because with Newton's laws of motion you could predict the behavior of everything: how a baseball moves, how rockets move, how the planets move. People began to think of the world as a big mechanism, like a giant clock. If you know where things are now, you can use Newton's equations to predict where they'll be tomorrow.
There's a famous story about the mathematician Laplace in the Napoleonic era. He wrote a big book of mathematics and physics. Napoleon flipped through it and said, "I don't see God anywhere in your book." Laplace answered, "Sire, I have no need of that hypothesis." You might think Laplace was an atheist, but he wasn't. The common view of his time was that maybe God wound up the clock and then let it go, without interfering. What do we call that view?
Audience: Deism.
Yes, deism. God may exist, but he doesn't stick his fingers in. So deists became opposed to miracles, because a miracle would be God poking his finger into the clock. They thought that would mess up science, because the whole point of Newton's equations is that you can predict what happens tomorrow. If you're a deist, no miracle is allowed on philosophical grounds.
C.S. Lewis wrote a great book called Miracles, and I think his key point gets back to what Joseph understood. We shouldn't say science says miracles are impossible, because science deals with the natural world, and a miracle involves the supernatural.
Lewis gives an illustration I first read when I was about 20, and I still remember it. Think about billiards, which is like pool but somehow more boring. Billiards is great for taking Newton's equations for a ride. I strike the cue ball with a certain force at a certain angle. You do your calculations and say it will bounce off the wall, hit the other ball, and that ball will go in the pocket. Newton's equations say so.
So Mark and I do the experiment. We know it's going to happen. I hit the cue ball, and Mark grabs it right after I hit it. Science said the ball would go in the pocket, and it didn't. Did we disprove science? No. You engineers have a good habit: when you do a physics problem like that, you draw a dotted line around the table and say, "Here's my system," and you assume nothing outside the system interferes. It just so happened that assumption wasn't true, because Mark decided to grab the ball.
So what is a miracle? It is not a natural law being violated. Mark didn't violate natural law. He reached in from outside the table and changed something. That is what a miracle is: God reaching in from outside the table and changing something. Just as Mark didn't violate the laws of physics, God doesn't violate them when he does a miracle. Once you admit the possibility of God, miracles become possible.
You'll see arguments that go like this. Premise one: natural forces can't cause a dead person to come back to life. I think that's true. But then they skip premise two, which they never state but always assume: there are only natural forces. Conclusion: a dead person cannot be raised. If you allow for the possibility of God, premise two is false. Our assumption of a closed system might be wrong, and God could reach in and raise someone from the dead. People assume premise two and then act as if they've proven miracles impossible. This happens all the time.
Here's an example from an atheist at a recent conference: "Modern cell biology has radically undermined the credibility of the virgin birth, because it would require God making a Y chromosome out of nothing in Mary's ovum." If you believe in God, does that bother you? No. Of course God can do that.
So the real reason people say there are only natural forces is either that they don't believe God exists, or they think that to be a scientist they have to assume God won't reach onto the table. They worry that if God might reach in, all their experiments could go wrong. Think of Bunsen and Beaker. If God might reach in and mess up my experiment tomorrow, or make one of my socks disappear in the dryer, my scientific career is over. That's the fear of a capricious, trickster god.
This is where Christians have an answer. Yes, God has the ability to reach into the natural world and do a miracle, but he does not do so capriciously. He is not going to mess up your experiment for fun. Christians understand miracles as happening within a religious context.
Here's an example. Jesus is teaching a crowd, and some men bring a paralyzed man to him, lowering him through the roof because of the crowds. Jesus tells him, "Your sins are forgiven." Some people around him object. Jesus asks which is easier to say, "Your sins are forgiven," or "Get up and walk." Then, so they will know that the Son of Man has authority, he tells the man to get up and walk, and he is healed. The point isn't only that the man's life got easier. The miracle makes a larger point about who Jesus is. Miracles are not random. They have a purpose. That's why, as a scientist, you can go to your lab and be confident God isn't going to tamper with your experiment for fun.
So miracles are naturally impossible, but we don't claim miracles are natural. We say they are supernatural. If you tell Joseph a virgin birth is impossible, he'd say, "I know science says a virgin birth is naturally impossible. But I don't think this is a natural situation. Something supernatural is happening here." And he'd be right.
That one is actually true. There may be a lot of Christians who are anti-science, especially here in the U.S., and there are many sociological reasons for that. So for those of you who are Christians, be careful about speaking out against the scientific establishment. Keep your powder dry for when it really matters. Going back to Augustine, the early church fathers warned that if Christians speak ignorantly on a topic, we may put barriers to the gospel in place for no good reason. Please proceed with caution.
Some of you mentioned apologetics questions like creation, evolution, and where life came from. We need to proceed with caution, because science studies the natural world, not the supernatural world. This question can be handled poorly.
Here's an example. Bill O'Reilly had an atheist on his show and wanted to name something the atheist couldn't explain without God. Of all the things he could have picked, he said, "The tide goes in, the tide goes out. You can't explain that." Sadly, the atheist didn't know what causes the tides either. He said, "I can't explain it now, but I'm sure there's a scientific explanation." You could imagine thirteen-year-olds yelling at their TVs: it's the moon! It was frustrating to watch, and it inspired memes like "Bread goes in, toast comes out. You can't explain that."
That's a god of the gaps argument: there's a gap in our understanding, so God must do it. Try not to argue from gaps in our understanding, because as our scientific understanding grows, those gaps may get smaller. I got to spend time with Richard Dawkins a few months ago, and his view is that every argument for God works this way: there's a gap, we explain it with God, and eventually science fills the gap. Some of that view comes from hearing arguments like these.
So I'd offer a different perspective. Science can't study the supernatural, so science can't prove God. But it can make you suspicious. Here are a couple of examples.
For a long time there was a debate about whether our universe began at some point in the past. Thomas Aquinas thought that if the universe had a beginning, that would point to God. Then, as Big Bang cosmology developed, it began to look like our physical space-time universe really did begin at some point in the past. So where did it come from? Did it pop into existence out of nothing? That's hard to understand. The physicist Lawrence Krauss, now at Arizona State, wrote a book called A Universe from Nothing, with an afterword by Richard Dawkins. He argued that an energy field with an average energy of zero can have quantum fluctuations, and a universe could come from that. But readers pointed out that's not nothing. If you genuinely start with nothing, it's very hard to explain where a universe could come from. If there is a cause outside the universe, science can't probe it. But that does sound suspicious.
Another example, which I believe Dr. Mike Strauss spoke about here at Embry-Riddle a few years ago, is fine-tuning. Dawkins told me he thinks it's the most interesting argument for the existence of God. The physical constants, like the mass of the electron, the speed of light, and the gravitational constant, didn't have to be what they are. Physicists can simulate what kind of universe we'd get if we changed them. In one region you can't get carbon or heavier elements. In another, chemical reactions are impossible. In another, you can't even get hydrogen. There is a narrow slice where you get a universe like ours, with complex chemistry and life. There are many graphs like this. Change the constants a little and you get a universe that's all hydrogen or all helium, unable to support life.
If those constants didn't have to be what they are, but they are fine-tuned to allow us to be here, that should make you suspicious. An atheist will usually answer that maybe there is an infinite number of universes and we're in the lucky one. That's possible. The other possibility is that when you see fine-tuning, someone fine-tuned it. These don't prove God, but they make you think.
I want to end with the question that has helped me most in thinking about whether there's more to the universe than atoms and energy: how do our minds work, and how are they able to understand the universe in the first place?
I'll be a little autobiographical. In early 2003 I was a graduate student at MIT. Anyone who has lived in Boston knows your first winter there will be long, dark, and cold, and you won't be ready for it. During that winter I began to wonder about my materialist friends. What if they're right? What if there is no supernatural, no God, no afterlife, and when you die the lights just go out? Not like sleep. You simply stop existing. And eventually the whole universe undergoes heat death, and everything you value comes to nothing. No purpose, no ethics. If materialism is true and the universe is only matter and energy, that's the consequence. And I thought that was pretty depressing.
Then I thought, "I'm a Christian. What if I only believe in Christianity because I want it to be true?" I got very skeptical of myself, and I lost a lot of sleep. If we're just atoms and energy, it's not only depressing, but there's nothing you can do about it except lose sleep and feel that existential angst. I really struggled.
A few things brought me out of that season of doubt. One was reading a lot of J.R.R. Tolkien. That might sound like it doesn't matter, but it does. As spring came in 2003 and the sun and the plants came back, I'd walk by the Charles River and think: if we lived in an accidental universe that is a meaningless collection of atoms, it would be hard to explain the beauty we see. I'd expect the world to be much more gray and boring. Instead I see a world with narrative and story, much more like Tolkien's stories than the drab world materialism would predict. That implies we're living in a story with an author. I think that's biblical. The psalmist says, "One thing I have asked of the Lord, that will I seek after: that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to gaze upon the beauty of the Lord and to inquire in his temple." I couldn't square myself with the idea that beauty is something we just make up.
The other thing that brought me out was this question. If materialism is true, what does that say about my mind? It means I don't really have a mind, just a brain. Everything I think of as rational is really biochemistry. And not only my rationality, but my first-person conscious experience. Right now I'm experiencing life from behind my own eyes, and I think you are too. That's what we mean by consciousness. Materialism says that's just biochemistry as well, and that has some problems.
Francis Crick, of Crick and Watson, said: "Your joys and your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will, are in fact no more than the behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated molecules." That's reductionism: there is nothing more to you than biochemistry.
But rephrase it so Crick is talking about himself: "My joys and sorrows, my memories and ambitions, my sense of personal identity and free will, are no more than the behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells." Then you should ask, "Why should I listen to you? You're just a biochemical experiment."
If you think I'm exaggerating the problem, here's a remarkable quote: "With me the horrid doubt always arises whether the convictions of man's mind, which has been developed from the mind of the lower animals, are of any value or at all trustworthy. Would any one trust in the convictions of a monkey's mind, if there are any convictions in such a mind?" Believe it or not, that's Charles Darwin. He's asking: if that's all we are, why are we listening to ourselves? I had that exact thought late one night in the spring of 2003.
Here's how it plays out. Nicholas Wade wrote in the New York Times that religion has the hallmarks of an evolved behavior, favored by natural selection and wired into our neural circuitry. So imagine texting Nicholas. He says, "You have religious beliefs because they're wired into your neural circuitry." You reply, "Did you make that statement because it's wired into your neural circuitry?" He'd have to say, "I don't know." Anyone who says you only believe something because you're wired that way has to turn the knife on themselves. If you explain rationality away on the basis of materialism, you explain yourself away. It is self-defeating.
Anybody recognize this little thing?
Audience: A Tamagotchi.
I thought those were only popular in the '90s. A Tamagotchi is a little electronic pet, and if you neglect it, it eventually dies. On the way, it cries, "Feed me." I had a friend in the '90s who would purposely neglect his Tamagotchi and ignore its pitiful cries until it died. I thought this person was going to end up in prison. The same friend found a code that gave Mario 99 lives, then taped the controller so Mario would walk to his death over and over in some kind of Mario purgatory. A disturbed individual, right?
But here's the question. Do you actually feel bad for the Tamagotchi? Do you feel bad for Mario? You don't, because they don't feel pain the way you do. If you were starved, you would have a first-person, conscious experience of pain. A Tamagotchi is a little computer programmed to make a noise when neglected. That's it.
The problem is that if materialism is true and you are merely a biochemical computer, it is very hard to explain the difference between you and the Tamagotchi. You'd just be programmed to give responses to certain stimuli, with no inner life. At this point you should say, "But that's not true. I know I have a conscious experience." That's right. If someone tells you you're not really conscious, feel free not to listen.
If you think I'm joking, there was a Time magazine headline on a Steven Pinker article: "The Mystery of Consciousness. You exist, right? Prove it." It asked how a hundred billion jabbering neurons create the knowledge, or illusion, that you're here. Imagine René Descartes saying, "I think, therefore I am," and someone answering, "No, you're not." If materialism points someone to say you don't exist, something is wrong with materialism.
Here's another example. What color is this? Red and green. But there's a certain redness I see, and a certain redness you see, and it's possible they aren't the same. Here's the unbelievable thing: there is no way to check. No scientific experiment can tell us. We call that qualia, the subjective experience of what red looks like. The fact that there is something in our minds science cannot probe should bother a materialist. Some have even concluded that consciousness and qualia don't exist. A cartoon of the materialist philosopher Daniel Dennett sums it up with a love poem: "Roses are red, violets are blue, qualia don't exist, and neither do you." If you hold to materialism all the way, you conclude that consciousness isn't real and you aren't real. I can't go there. If someone tells me I have to believe something I know to be false, I can't go there.
If you remember one thing from tonight, remember this. There will be moments when someone says, "Give me evidence that there's anything in this world beyond atoms and energy." You have beautiful evidence: you have a mind that is rational, conscious, and moral.
If your rationality is real, you are more than just material. If you have a subjective conscious self, you are more than material. And if morality is real, not just biochemistry or human convention but a real feature of the universe about how we should and shouldn't live, then there is more to this world than atoms. So if you have those existential, doubting moments like I did as a grad student, remember: there is evidence that there is more to this world than atoms, and much of it is revealed in your own mind.
As a Christian, I believe this is part of what it means that we are created in God's image. The Bible says, "God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them." Being made in God's image means many things, including your dignity and value. I think it also includes these: rationality, first-person consciousness, and a sense of right and wrong.
I'll end here. Unlike the stereotype that science and faith are diametrically opposed, I think Christianity has a lot to offer the scientific mind. As a scientist, you have to make certain assumptions. You have to believe that what you sense and measure is reliable. You have to assume the universe is understandable and orderly, that it follows regular laws, acts the same tomorrow as yesterday, and that the laws of physics are the same on Mars as they are here. And you have to assume your mind is reliable, that it can figure out how the universe is made.
If you're a materialist, I don't know why you get to make those assumptions, especially the last one. How do you know your mind is reliable if it's just a biochemical accident that evolved to survive and reproduce? Even the second one is up for grabs. Albert Einstein said, "The eternal mystery of the world is its comprehensibility. The fact that it is comprehensible is a miracle." We take for granted that we can use our minds to understand the world, but people haven't always believed that.
In fact, the early scientists were almost all Christians, and they answered these assumptions by saying: the universe is understandable and orderly because God made it. My mind is reliable because God made my mind. And God made my mind intending that I would go out and understand the universe. Christians have a religious motivation to do science. God made the universe, God made the laws of physics, and he wants me to use my mind to understand how they work, because when I understand something about how he made the universe, I can glorify him.
If you think I'm making that up, look at people like Kepler and Pascal. Kepler said these laws of nature "are within the grasp of the human mind. God wanted us to recognize them by creating us after his own image so that we could share in his own thoughts."
That means that when a student here at Embry-Riddle makes a discovery and becomes the first human to understand something, you are the first human to understand that part of physical law since God. Imagine walking into someone's workshop full of amazing inventions and designs, looking at how they built something, and saying, "Oh, I see what you did there. That's cool." That's basically what science is. We look at what God has made and say, "I see what you did there. That's awesome." And that is how we worship.
So instead of picturing science and faith as opposed, see faith as providing the motivation and the assumptions we need to get science moving. Science and faith come together. With that, I'll close. Thank you so much.
Having a hard time right now?
Someone will answer day or night.