How do you judge between competing worldviews? A short set of tests for weighing what is true, from the same habits you use in research.

How should I compare qualities of worldviews? This is one author’s synopsis of the criteria for a worldview test.
D1: p is a defining belief of R if and only if being an active participant in good standing within the religious community of R entails acceptance of p.
D2: A religion R is true if and only if all of its defining beliefs are true; if any of its defining beliefs are false, then R is false.
P1: If a defining belief p of a religion R is self-contradictory then p is false.
P2: If two or more defining beliefs of R are mutually contradictory at least one of them must be false.
P3: If a defining belief p of R is self-defeating it cannot reasonably be accepted as true.
P4: If the defining beliefs of R are not coherent in the sense of providing a unified perspective on the world, then R cannot plausibly be regarded as true.
P5: Any religious worldview which is unable to account for fundamental phenomena associated with a religious orientation or which cannot provide adequate answers to central questions in religion should not be accepted as true.
P6: If a defining belief p of R contradicts well-established conclusions in other domains, and if R cannot justify doing so, then p should be rejected as probably false.
P7: If a defining belief p of R depends upon a belief in another domain (e.g., history) which there is good reason to reject as false, then there is good reason to reject p as probably false.
P8: If one or more defining beliefs of R are incompatible with widely accepted and well-established moral values and principles; or if R includes among its essential practices or rites activities which are incompatible with basic moral values and practices, then there is good reason for rejecting R as false.
P9: If the defining beliefs of R entail the denial of the objectivity of basic moral values and principles; or if they entail the denial of the objective distinction between right and wrong, good and evil, then there is good reason for rejecting R as false.
P10: If R is unable to provide adequate answers to basic questions about the phenomena of moral awareness this provides good reason for rejecting R as false.
To read more, see Dissonant Voices: Religious Pluralism and the Question of Truth by Harold A. Netland (pages 192 to 193).
If anything here touches something heavy for you, you do not have to carry it alone. Someone will answer day or night.
Find a mentor in your field or find your people on campus.